The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

By Timothy Timothy | Posted at 11:41

Here is a story. The leaders of a church have a personal agenda against someone and want to quiet him, exact revenge or what have you. They not only come at him within their church, they continue by following him outside of that church to any other church he seeks refuge at and any place he works, making a wreck of his life in the process. That is the sort of thing that only happened in the past, in dusty tales of witch-hunts in Salem or the Inquisition in Spain, right? Wrong: it is happening today, perhaps at a seemingly normal church near you.

Within the Church there is a certain group of people who are lamenting the fading influence of church discipline. As it is supposed to be, church discipline is merely an unpleasant sounding term for a process focused on encouraging and strengthening people. Yes, that includes a proper rebuke when people act immorally and yet want to participate in the church for the status or as some sort of ersatz payment for weekday misdeeds.

But not everyone is satisfied with church discipline stopping at this juncture. Groups such as Ken Sande’s Peacemaker Ministries – a group whose materials are becoming increasingly in vogue in Evangelical circles – have sought to encourage a greater level of accountability for those attending a church.

Why? In an article for Christianity Today a few years ago, Sande, a lawyer by training, told a story of a “respected businessman” who swindled people in the church he attended. The congregants sought help from the pastor, but the church’s desire to censure the man was cut short when his attorney called and “successfully intimidated” the church from proceeding. In a second church where the same scenario played out, however, those attending had given what is known as “informed consent,” waiving their rights to litigate over the church’s censures and discipline. As such, this church was able to insure the sinful man had to submit, albeit “resentfully,” to the “loving admonishment of his elders.” Of course, the story ends well, with everyone confessing their misdeeds and forgiving each other.

A happy ending is such a beautiful thing! Is it not wonderful that a church can strongly encourage its members to act morally? Yes, but not if the cost includes granting unchecked power to church leaders, power that could potentially do great harm instead of great good.

The danger of informed consent is highlighted by the story I began with. It provides legal cover to the leadership of a church, but lacks any concern for protecting the rights of those in the church. While sinful members of a congregation are anecdotally discussed in copious detail to assist in garnering support for the Peacemaking program, discussions of sinful leadership misusing the program are conspicuously missing. What happens when the pastor or leaders of a church are themselves unethical or, at the least, misguided?

Presented with stories about unscrupulous people set right by the policies of “the Peacemaking Church” and a handful of apt Bible passages, congregations are told that they really are not consenting to anything other than the Bible itself (and, maybe, a little commonsense). Everything sounds so good and noble, most people will likely consent without really understanding all they have signed onto. Moreover, once brought into a church, informed consent offers only one option to those who wish not to consent: leave.

Faced with losing their church, those who might otherwise resist come under enormous pressure to “go with the flow.” The cost, after all, is greater than mere organizational membership. If your friends and acquaintances bought into the glowing “Peacemaking” anecdotes and presentations, they will be given the impression that dissenters are troublemakers who reject the Bible and commonsense.

Let’s be clear: to reject the Peacemaking Church has nothing to do with rejecting the Church.

SOURCE: Library of Congress

Once a person enters into informed consent under this “biblical” system, the person not only is unable to seek protection through the courts if the leadership decides to publicly air whatever “concerns” they feel ought to be broadcast about a person, the victim is also unable to resign from the church until the leadership wishes to allow him or her to leave and the leadership is also free to spread word of the person’s alleged sins to other churches the accused may seek refuge at.

The person on the wrong side of this process faces “prosecution” in a system with little room for fair appeals or due process. This troubling situation necessitates trying to prove innocence under an almost certain assumption of guilt: after all, most people will by default favor the testimony of respectable leaders of the community – the pastor and his supportive leadership.

Of course, when the informed consent concept is presented within a church, it is not presented in such blunt terms. Instead, members hear about the importance of “relational commitments,” an emphasis on “Biblical conflict resolution” and so on – euphemisms that may send a chill down the spine of anyone who has been hurt by the program, but which otherwise sound so good and noble that it seems almost unbiblical to argue against them. Newspeak is not limited to the realm of governments.

Like so many programs before it, “Peacemaking” has become a hot commodity, the sort of thing churches that want to be trendy participate in. Alarmingly, however, unlike former hit programs that permeated “church pop culture” and intended to give one a better sense of God’s plan or a more balanced financial position, long after this one’s glimmer fades, the broad powers it encourages churches to give their leadership remain.

That significant power allotted to the leaders of the church may be given with the goal of making it easier to do what is right, but it is neither biblical nor wise to grant. The totalitarian state can be efficient, but it is a brutal and unjust efficiency. Tyranny has often gained power by presenting what sounded like commonsense, reasonable reforms aimed at accomplishing the good, yet in reality does so only at too great of cost, if at all.

The reason we have constitutional rights has little to do with efficiency and everything to do with justice. The lessons acknowledged in documents such as the Bill of Rights apply throughout life, even church life. The Bible itself is keenly aware of abuses of power. What else can be said, for example, of the powerful leaders who conspired to kill Jesus and hush the Apostles? Given its familiarity with humanity’s general inclinations towards sin, making a case that the Bible encourages granting unilateral power is very difficult.

Whether Peacemaker Ministries itself intends its ideas to enable abuse of power is not even a necessary part of the question. I prefer to think they do not, though they are, at best, naïve to believe that giving such broad, one-sided power to a small leadership body is advisable.

Unclear initial intentions aside, the dangers of the informed consent are clear because grants of massive and unchecked powers generate a predictable result. As this popular program spreads to more and more churches, announced in wonderful, common sense terms, another bit of common sense is worth remembering.

Power corrupts.

Timothy R. Butler is Editor-in-Chief of Open for Business. Have a story about Peacemaker Ministries' program or other similar programs? Tim would like to hear your story; write him at

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Brother, while we agree on many particulars of church doctrine, I must disagree with your assessment and critique of the Peacemaker movement in general and Peacemaker Ministries in particular. I think you have painted an incomplete picture of what the Peacemaking model is about. While I'm sure there are self serving pastors/elders which strip away portions of the concept they don't like and abuse the model to their own ends, that is not the norm.

I have helped several churches implement a Peacemaker type model or system of dispute resolution. These churches are all healthier for it. Not one has degenerated into an abuse of power. In fact, the various covenants, if implemented properly do hold the elders as accountable as the average member. The church discipline process cuts both ways.

To be sure, any system can be abused, and the Peacemaker model is not perfect precisely because it is implemented and administered by totally depraved humans. We do need to guard against abuses. I think though that you have gone overboard and not represented the movement accurately.


Posted by Jason P. Franklin - Jan 9, 2010 | 18:28

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

The best intentions will fry on the fire of false assumptions. Peacemakers appears built on the assumption a church ought to be like any other modern corporation, just nicer. The problem is, too many churches are run by men and women who think like CEOs and not always that much nicer.

Worse, the people who manage this program at the regional level are the ones who often advise the most unconscionable harassment using the mechanism of these relational contracts. While such action is likely contrary to Peacemakers teaching materials, why does nothing happen to correct their behavior? Contracts are Satan's answer to spiritual covenants. Contracts are as impersonal as can be, where covenants are entirely personal. Churches have no business pretending to operate like corporations.

Posted by Ed Hurst - Jan 11, 2010 | 18:23

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

It all sounds like a witch hunt to me,and the stoning of may people will much hidden information leads to bad things and NO one should sign a cnotract of any kind with satan the snake charmer.

Posted by L Meier - Jan 18, 2010 | 18:43

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Good post! Thanks for sharing. Really very useful and informative post.

Posted by baozha - Jun 30, 2017 | 13:21

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by nikhil sharma - Jul 1, 2017 | 11:12

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by nikhil sharma - Jul 1, 2017 | 11:12

Posted by Mike - Jul 2, 2017 | 14:58

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers


Posted by contestwingo - Jul 2, 2017 | 20:29

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by Jenis - Jul 2, 2017 | 20:32

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by Contact Support Number - Jul 3, 2017 | 9:37

Posted by Mikey - Jul 4, 2017 | 11:28

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by nomi - Jul 5, 2017 | 11:24

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by Junaid Shahid - Jul 6, 2017 | 10:18

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by abhishek - Jul 7, 2017 | 15:15

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Nice! thank you so much! Thank you for sharing. Your blog posts are more interesting and informative. I think there are many people like and visit it regularly, including me.

Posted by baozha - Jul 8, 2017 | 14:06

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Amazingly, the information you provide is very qualified and also very useful for me as a reader, hopefully you selau in giving smooth and more successful. Sorry I am sharing information for you hopefully useful :
Obat Penyakit Kudis

Posted by adnanpitrian - Jul 10, 2017 | 6:02

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Offerscontest is web site which provides International Giveaway, Sweepstakes online contest, Competition, Offers, Free Sample, Freebies, Loot, Quiz, Survey, Tricks, Web Loot, Facebook Contest, Twitter Contest, Instagram Contest, Audition, Registration, Coupons, Deals and other Details to win daily big prizes such as Autograph, Bicycle, Bike, Bookmyshow Voucher, Car, Cash, Flipkart Voucher, Gifts, Headphone, iPhone, LED, Laptops, Mobile, Paytm Cash, Phone, Powerbank, Prizes, Free Recharge.

Offers Contest

Visit Daily for All Type of Contests & Giveaway to win Big Prizes.

Posted by Offerscontest - Jul 10, 2017 | 16:35

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Wherever we go, we should keep peace and love. Without peace, everything can't works smoothly.

Posted by Digital Marketing Indianapolis - Jul 11, 2017 | 8:18

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Peaceful will bring good life for you and others around you. So, we need to mutual respect one each others.

Posted by Townhomes in Houston - Jul 11, 2017 | 9:27

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Wonderful article, thanks for putting this together! This is obviously one great post.

Posted by - Jul 12, 2017 | 9:36

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Great post,Thanks a lot for the kind of perfect topic I have not a lot of information about it but I have got an extra unique info in your unique post.
Delhi Escort
Mahipalpur Escorts
Call Girls in South Ex
Escorts in Lajpat Nagar
Escorts in Friends Colony
Escorts in Greater Kailash

Posted by Delhi - Jul 12, 2017 | 11:29

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

One of the best article to see this impressive post which i need to explore more. Delighted to see this impressive post.
Escorts in New Delhi
Dwarka Escorts
Mahipalpur Escorts
Escorts in Malviya Nagar

Posted by Candice Clings - Jul 12, 2017 | 11:57

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

I feel a lot more people need to read this, very good info! … …

Posted by <a href=''>internet</a> - Jul 13, 2017 | 8:11

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

you can find so many interesting stuff about german women in the world

Posted by hot german - Jul 13, 2017 | 9:37

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by Junaid Shahid - Jul 13, 2017 | 16:53

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by sag - Jul 13, 2017 | 22:55

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by Junaid Shahid - Jul 14, 2017 | 16:38

Happy New Year 2018 Images,Wishes,Quotes,Greetings HAPPY NEW YEA
Posted by happy new year 2018 images wishes quotes - Jul 15, 2017 | 7:40

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Your article is awesome! How long does it take to complete this article? I have read through other blogs, but they are cumbersome and confusing. I hope you continue to have such quality articles to share with everyone! I believe there will be many people who share my views when they read this article from you!

Posted by slither io - Jul 15, 2017 | 9:19

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Thanks for your article! I have been looking for quite a long time and fortunately I read this article! I wish you would continue to have valuable articles like this or more to share with everyone!

Posted by abcya - Jul 17, 2017 | 5:25

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

very well written and all the best for further articles

Posted by Guru - Jul 17, 2017 | 7:48

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

As businessman, I always try to update my self with new information to improve my skills. By do that, your business will run smoothly. Manchester airport transfers

Posted by Manchester airport transfers - Jul 17, 2017 | 8:24

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers
Posted by Jessica - Jul 20, 2017 | 10:13

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Peacemaking is sleeping at the rainy days.
wrought iron chandeliers

Posted by Natalie Floyd - Jul 20, 2017 | 13:08

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Very nice website.

Posted by Independence Day Quotes - Jul 20, 2017 | 20:55

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Great website.Thanks

Posted by Independence Day Quotes - Jul 20, 2017 | 20:57

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

I want to go somewhere with so many sunshine and quite.
Diving Phuket

Posted by ElizaDavis - Jul 21, 2017 | 6:34

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers


Posted by Raksha Bandhan Images - Jul 21, 2017 | 17:07

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Happy Raksha Bandhan HD Images
Happy Raksha Bandhan 2017 Images
Happy Raksha Bandhan Gif Images
Happy Raksha Bandhan SMS
Happy Raksha Bandhan Shayari
Happy Raksha Bandhan Messages
Happy Friendship Day FB Profile Pics
Happy Friendship Day Whatsapp DP
<a href=””>Happy

Friendship Day Animated Images</a>
<a href=””>Happy

Friendship Day GIF Images</a>

Posted by raaj - Jul 22, 2017 | 8:37

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

<a href=””>Happy

Friendship Day HD Images</a>
<a href=””>Happy

Friendship Day HD Photos</a>
Happy Friendship Day Gift Ideas
Happy Friendship Day SMS
Happy Friendship Day Shayari
Happy Friendship Day Messages
Happy Friendship Day FB Status
Happy Friendship Day Whatsapp Status

Posted by raaj - Jul 22, 2017 | 8:39

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Friendship Day Gifts
Friendship Day 2017 Funny SMS
<a href=””>Friendship Day 2017 Funny

Friendship Day 2017 Status
Friendship Day 2017 FB Status
Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
<a href=””>Friendship Day Shayari

<a href=””>Friendship Day Hindi

<a href=””>Friendship Day

Friendship Day Whatsapp Dp For gf
Friendship Day Whatsapp Dp For BF
Friendship Day Whatsapp Profile Pics For BF
Friendship Day Shayari For Girlfriend

Posted by raaj - Jul 22, 2017 | 8:40

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

15 August Speech In Marathi
Raksha Bandhan 2017 Hd Wallpapers
Raksha Bandhan 2017 Hd Images
Rakhi Images For Bro
Rakhi Images 2017
Raksha Bandhan Bhajan Songs
Raksha Bandhan Songs
Raksha Bandhan Shayari
Rakhi SMS Shayari
Raksha Bandhan Hindi Poems
<a href=””>Happy Friendship Day HD

Happy Friendship Day DP
<a href=””>Happy Friendship Day Whatsapp

DP </a>
<a href=””>Happy Friendship Day FB DP


Happy Friendship Day sms
Happy Friendship Day shayari
Happy Friendship Day sms 2017
Happy Friendship Day Gif Images
Happy Friendship Day Animated Images
<a href=””>Happy Friendship

Day Advance SMS</a>

Posted by raaj - Jul 22, 2017 | 8:41


Posted by ashasia123 ashasia123 - Jul 22, 2017 | 9:37

escorts in uttarakhand

It is truly a great and useful piece of info. I am satisfied that you simply shared
this helpful info with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing

Posted by SHIVANI - Jul 24, 2017 | 6:16

tcm diagnosis online

I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.

Posted by tcm diagnosis online - Jul 24, 2017 | 12:37

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Hi there, I found your blog via Google while searching for such kinda informative post and your post looks very interesting for me.

Posted by devidmiller5060 - Jul 25, 2017 | 13:01

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.

Posted by Eid Ul Adha 2017 - Jul 25, 2017 | 20:25

Re: The Hidden Danger of Peacemakers

Programmable Peripheral Interface
Microcontrollers - 8051 Interrupts
Microcontrollers 8051 Input Output Ports
Microcontrollers - 8051 Pin Description
Microcontrollers - 8051 Architecture
Microcontrollers - Overview
How does a Microcontroller work?
Microcontroller v/s microprocessor
What is a Microcontroller?

C# Interfaces
C# More abstract classes
C# Abstract classes
C# Inheritance
C# Static members
C# Visibility
C# Method overloading
C# Constructors and destructors
C# classes Properties
Introduction to C# classes

Arduino Time
Arduino String Object
Arduino Strings
Arduino Functions
Arduino Loops
Arduino Control Statements
Arduino Operators
Arduino Variables & Constants
Arduino Data Types
Arduino - Program Structure

C++ Program to Print Number Entered by User
C++ Program to Add Two Numbers
C++ Program to Find Quotient and Remainder
C++ Program to Swap Two Numbers
C++ Program to Check Whether Number is Even or Odd
C++ Program to Check Whether a character is Vowel or Consonant
C++ Program to Find Largest Number Among Three Numbers
C++ Program to Find All Roots of a Quadratic Equation
C++ Program to Calculate Sum of Natural Numbers
C++ Program to Check Leap Year

C Program to Count Number of Digits in an Integer
C Program to Display Characters from A to Z Using Loop
C Program to Find LCM of two Numbers
C Program to Find GCD of two Numbers
C Program to Display Fibonacci Sequence
C Program to Generate Multiplication Table
C Program to Find Factorial of a Number
C Program to Calculate the Sum of Natural Numbers
C Program to Check Whether a Character is an Alphabet or not
C Program to Check Whether a Number is Positive or Negative

C Program to Make a Simple Calculator Using switch…case
C Programming Code To Create Pyramid and Pattern
C Program to Display Factors of a Number
C Program to Display Armstrong Number Between Two Intervals
C Program to Check Armstrong Number
C Program to Display Prime Numbers Between Two Intervals
C Program to Check Whether a Number is Prime or Not
C Program to Check Whether a Number is Palindrome or Not
C Program to Calculate the Power of a Number
C Program to Reverse a Number

Posted by TEPJunaid - Jul 26, 2017 | 13:15

Re:quicken support

call quicken call quicken support contact quicken contact quicken support quicken help quicken help chat quicken help desk quicken help line call quicken customer support intuit quicken customer service phone number intuit quicken customer support phone number quicken customer service quicken tech support quicken tech support number quicken tech support phone number quicken tech support telephone number quicken bill pay phone number quicken bill pay service quicken bill pay support quicken bill pay support phone number contact quicken by phone how to contact quicken by phone intuit quicken phone number quicken 800 number quicken online backup customer service quicken online backup support quicken online chat support quicken online help contact quicken support by phone intuit quicken support intuit quicken support phone number phone number for quicken support quicken support quicken support chat quicken support contact quicken support for mac quicken support number quicken support phone quicken support phone number telephone number for quicken support quicken chat support phone number for quicken quicken help number quicken help phone quicken help phone number quicken help support intuit quicken help help with quicken quicken customer service number quicken customer service phone quicken customer service phone number quicken customer support quicken customer support number quicken customer support phone quicken customer support phone number<a> <a href=””>quicken technical support quicken technical support telephone number quicken technical support chat quicken technical support number quicken technical support phone number quicken bill pay customer service quicken contact quicken contact number quicken contact phone number quicken contact us quicken intuit phone number quicken intuit support quicken number quicken phone quicken phone number quicken phone number for support quicken phone support quicken phone support number quicken telephone number quicken telephone support quicken toll free number quicken online help chat quicken online services quicken online support quicken online support chat quicken backup support

Posted by david warner94 - Jul 26, 2017 | 13:43

Please enter your comment entry below. Press 'Preview' to see how it will look.

Sign In to Your Account
User Name:
:mrgreen: :neutral: :twisted: :arrow: :shock: :smile: :???: :cool: :evil: :grin: :idea: :oops: :razz: :roll: :wink: :cry: :eek: :lol: :mad: :sad: :!: :?:
Home About Connect: Twitter Facebook RSS
© 2001-2012 Universal Networks, All Rights Reserved. Some content rights may be held by Universal Networks' providers and used under license. Powered by ServerForest and SAFARI. Learn about our privacy policy here.